USA Today published an article that details how over 180 cities across the country have reverted to the practice of shaming in a low cost attempt to reduce prostitution.
Different cities are using different methods. "Chicago, New York, Denver, St. Louis and Madison, Wis., are among the cities that publicize arrests or send letters home, a USA TODAY review of policies showed."
Some cities use city television stations and local news media to publicize the names and pictures of "Johns" as well as prostitutes.
Asheville, N.C., police began showcasing arrested prostitutes and their clients on the city's website and television channel in February. The action has been criticized by the ACLU.
The American Civil Liberties Union claims it is punishment prior to conviction.
Asheville police also send "Suspicious Activity Notice" postcards to owners of cars spotted possibly cruising for prostitutes, Riddle said.
The use of shaming as a means of controlling behavior that is unacceptable to the community goes back to tribal law and customs.
When I read the article, I was reminded of Wilson's Broken Windows Theory.
Indianapolis brings clients together several times a year with residents of the neighborhood they trolled. Since 1999, convicts have listened to stories of children unable to play on sidewalks littered with used needles and condoms, said Diane Hannell, the Marion County, Ind., community prosecution administrator.
Hannell said just 2% of graduates of the Red Zone program have been arrested again after nine years. Over that time, nearly 400 clients have spent eight Saturday hours listening to residents and picking up trash, she said.
"There is great pride in this neighborhood, and some of the older ladies just really let these guys have it," said Jay Height, a pastor who helped found the program.
There are arguments put forth claiming that prostitution should be legalized so that health checks could be done to limit the sexually transmitted diseases and AIDS exposure that often result.
What do you think of the shaming methods used?
How do you feel about legalizing prostitution?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Posts
2 comments:
I don't think the shaming methods are a good idea, it casts a shadow over the presumption of innocence and creates a door for lawsuits. As for legalizing prostitution, history has shown us this act violates societies norms and is not acceptable.
Shaming would only be used after guilt is established by fact or confession. It has been shown in other societies to be very effective.
As for prostitution, there are many countries in the world with legalized prostitution. The prostitutes have regular medical check-ups which helps control the spread of many diseases.
In most areas of our country you can find women who accept money for sexual favors. They may not be called prostitutes, but there is little difference.
Thanks for posting an opinion
Post a Comment